Boy Scouts of America v. Dale

Summary

James Dale rose to the rank of Eagle Scout and was invited to become an assistant scoutmaster, only to be forced out in 1990 by the national Boy Scouts of America, when the organization’s leaders learned in a newspaper article that he is gay. Dale filed his lawsuit for reinstatement in the BSA — the first case to invoke New Jersey’s law prohibiting sexual orientation discrimination. In 1995, with a harshly worded opinion peppered with biblical allusions and references to “sodomy” and “buggery,” a lower court ruled against Dale, refusing to apply the New Jersey antidiscrimination law to the Boy Scouts and generally ignoring the case law governing other discrimination claims in New Jersey. Lambda Legal continued to fight on Dale’s behalf, winning landmark court victories in the New Jersey state appeals court and the New Jersey Supreme Court. In June of 2000, the U.S. Supreme Court, by a close 5–4 vote, overturned the unanimous New Jersey Supreme Court decision, ruling that because it is a private group the Boy Scouts had a constitutional right to exclude openly gay people from leadership positions.

Lambda Legal's Impact

Although this landmark Supreme Court case did not succeed in changing the Boy Scouts’ policy, Lambda Legal’s victories in the New Jersey courts, as well as the publicity surrounding the appearance before the Supreme Court, significantly advanced the national discussion about the needs of gay youth and the fitness of gay adults to participate in the iconic institution of the Boy Scouts. As a result of the education the case generated, numerous government bodies and nonprofit organizations have decided no longer to be affiliated with or support scouting, and the Boy Scouts have set up separate “Learning for Life” programs, which no longer discriminate based on sexual orientation, to maintain some of those ties.

History

  • July 29, 1992: Lambda Legal files complaint on behalf of Eagle Scout James Dale against the Boy Scouts of America in New Jersey Superior Court.
  • November 20, 1995: Trial court rules in favor of the Boy Scouts.
  • December 8, 1997: In the New Jersey intermediate appellate court, Lambda Legal presents oral argument that the Boy Scouts’ expulsion of Dale based on his sexual orientation violates the state’s anti-discrimination law.
  • March 2, 1998: Lambda Legal wins the first appellate court victory in the country against the Boy Scouts’ policy of anti-gay discrimination.
  • January 5, 1999: After the Boy Scouts appeals the intermediate appellate decision, Lambda Legal appears before the New Jersey Supreme Court to defend the victory it obtained on behalf of Dale.
  • August 4, 1999: The New Jersey Supreme Court unanimously holds that the anti-gay Scout ban violates New Jersey’s Law Against Discrimination.
  • January 14, 2000: The U.S. Supreme Court agrees to hear the Boy Scouts’ appeal of the New Jersey ruling.
  • March 29, 2000: Lambda Legal files its legal brief with the U.S. Supreme Court, urging the justices to uphold the New Jersey ruling.
  • April 26, 2000: Lambda Legal presents oral arguments before the U.S. Supreme Court.
  • June 28, 2000: By a close 5–4 vote, the U.S. Supreme Court holds that, as a private, expressive group, the Boy Scouts has a right to exclude from its leadership positions those who are openly gay.

Case Information

Status: Closed
Outcome: Landmark Case

Plaintiff

James Dale

Attorneys

Lambda Legal
David S. Buckel, Patricia M. Logue , Evan Wolfson, Ruth Harlow, Jon Davidson, Beatrice Dohrn